X-Git-Url: http://unremediatedgender.space/source?a=blobdiff_plain;f=notes%2Fmemoir-sections.md;h=219e3b38bd1917175b63fdb0241d1105b6fa96a4;hb=dda97b8ac1ab0aefe15ae15acc84b8dc5765e4c8;hp=a1e0786440aab9c424fd81f45fcb27c8710c317c;hpb=476160b2a1af4fb339eb48489d994f68958b3f39;p=Ultimately_Untrue_Thought.git diff --git a/notes/memoir-sections.md b/notes/memoir-sections.md index a1e0786..219e3b3 100644 --- a/notes/memoir-sections.md +++ b/notes/memoir-sections.md @@ -1,95 +1,44 @@ -first edit pass bookmark: "I got a chance to talk to" time-sensitive globals TODOs— -✓ address red team objections to pt. 3 -✓ schedule Friendship Day at Valinor -✓ apply pro edits to pt. 3 -✓ address auto edit tier to pt. 3 -✓ clear with Alicorn -- fill in needed pt. 4 sections -_ send pt. 4 to editors +_ rewrite pt. 4 _ consult Anna -_ clear with Steven -- rephrase "everyone-yelling operation" in pt. 5 -_ rephrase "trans kids on the margin" section: https://luminousalicorn.tumblr.com/post/702114588699820032/what-exactly-are-the-tell-tale-signs-of-a-3-year -_ clear with Kelsey -_ finish and ship "Reply to Scott on Autogenderphilia" -_ finish and ship "Hrunkner Unnerby" -_ clear with Michael/Ben/Jessica _ consult Said -_ clear with Ray -_ clear with Ruby -_ SHIP PT. 3!! ------------- -_ apply red team pt. 4 -_ apply pro edit pt. 4 +_ publish pt. 4 +-------- + +_ finish pt. 5 _ address auto edit tier to pt. 5 _ solicit red team pt. 5 _ solicit pro edit pt. 5 _ apply red team pt. 5 _ apply pro edit pt. 5 +✓ consult Tail + +_ bully Jeff Ladish +_ #drama strategy session + _ consult lc +_ consult David Xu _ psychiatric disaster private doc -pt. 3 edit tier (auto edition)— -✓ FTX aside footnote version -✓ revert alphabet names (from 17638259f20) -✓ narcissistic delusions -✓ clarify that cheerful price history is with Anna specifically -✓ screenshot "pleading, snarky reply" -✓ GreaterWrong over Less Wrong for comment links -✓ return on cognitive investment -✓ establish usage of "coordination group" vs. "posse" (posse) -✓ do I have a better identifier than "Vassarite" -✓ log2 with an 'o' -✓ yank note about LW comment policy to top-level -✓ "Common Interest of Many Causes" and "Kolmogorov Complicity" offer directly contradictory strategies -✓ re-check wording of trans-kids-on-the-margin section -_ briefly speculate on causes of brain damage in footnote? ----- -_ Ruby fight included ban threat, "forces of blandness want me gone ... stand my ground" remark -_ breakup song -_ being friends with dogs (it's good, but do I have the wordcount budget?) -_ mention that I was miffed about "Boundaries?" not getting Curated, while one of Euk's animal posts did -_ explicitly mention http://benjaminrosshoffman.com/bad-faith-behavior-not-feeling/ -_ meeting with Ray (maybe?) -_ mention Said rigor check somewhere, nervousness about Michael's gang being a mini-egregore -_ I should respond to Ziz's charges that my criticism of concept-policing was a form of concept-policing -_ Anna's claim that Scott was a target specifically because he was good, my counterclaim that payment can't be impunity -_ maybe I do want to fill in a few more details about the Sasha disaster, conditional on what I end up writing regarding Scott's prosecution?—and conditional on my separate retro email—also the Zolpidem thing -_ the "reducing negativity" post does obliquely hint at the regression point being general -_ link to protest flyer -_ "it was the same thing here"—most readers are not going to see an obvious analogy (editor might catch?) -_ better explanation of MOPs in "Social Reality" scuffle (editor might catch?) -_ better context on "scam" &c. earlier (editor might catch?) -_ cut words from descriptions of other posts! (editor might catch?) -_ try to clarify Abram's categories view (Michael didn't get it) (but it still seems clear to me on re-read?) - pt. 4 edit tier— -✓ "Ideology Is Not the Movement" mentions not misgendering -✓ mention Nick Bostrom email scandal (and his not appearing on the one-sentence CAIS statement) -✓ explain why he could think of some relevant differences -✓ rephrase "gamete size" discussion to make it clearer that Yudkowsky's proposal also implicitly requires people to be agree about the clustering thing -✓ honesty and humility, HEXACO -✓ GreaterWrong over Less Wrong for comment links -✓ ending qualifications on "fraud" and whether it might be a good idea -✓ selective argumentation that's clearly labeled as such would be fine - -- if you only say good things about Republican candidates / Stalin's five year plan -- he used to be worthy of trust +_ say that explicitly, up front, at the start of that … chunk. +_ edit post to clarify "nudging the cognition" +_ look for a place to link "Faction formation" +_ Tail's objection to FFS example _ the mailing list post noted it as a "common sexual fantasy" - ---- +_ Sept. 2020 clarification noted that a distinction should be made between _ emphasize that 2018 thread was policing TERF-like pronoun usage, not just disapproving of gender-based pronouns _ https://cognition.cafe/p/on-lies-and-liars _ cite more sneers; use a footnote to pack in as many as possible +_ Dawkins and Jerry Coyne and https://www.thefp.com/p/carole-hooven-why-i-left-harvard pt. 5 edit tier— -_ sucking Scott's dick is helpful because he's now the main gateway instead of HPMOR +✓ sucking Scott's dick is helpful because he's now the main gateway instead of HPMOR _ Previously-on summary _ graf about Christiano could use a rewrite _ Dolphin War: after "never been published", insert "still citing it" graf @@ -130,20 +79,21 @@ _ "Riley" pointing out that it worked better because it was Oli _ mention Michael's influence and South Park recs in late 2016? _ GreaterWrong over Less Wrong for comment links _ "List of Lethalities" mentioning quantilizers + https://twitter.com/ESYudkowsky/status/1301958048911560704 + https://twitter.com/paulfchristiano/status/1301992757007847425 +_ screenshot Xu thread -things to discuss with Michael/Ben/Jessica— -_ Anna on Paul Graham -_ Yudkowsky thinking reasoning wasn't useful -_ Jessica brought up race & IQ (she skimmed the previous draft, so I should highlight), or calling Ruby a MOP -_ Ben publish "Discursive Warfare and Faction Formation" doc? -_ footnote about FTX -_ revision of "yelling" description -_ Michael's SLAPP against REACH (new) -_ Michael on creepy and crazy men (new) -_ elided Sasha disaster (new) -_ what should I say to Iceman? -_ reached out to Garrison Lovely +Vassar et al.— +✓ "What You Can't Say" +✓ reached out to Garrison Lovely +✓ Michael on creepy and crazy men (new) +✓ Michael's SLAPP against REACH (new) +✓ elided Sasha disaster (new) +✓ Ben publish "Discursive Warfare and Faction Formation" doc? +✓ Yudkowsky thinking reasoning wasn't useful +✓ Jessica brought up race & IQ (she skimmed the previous draft, so I should highlight), or calling Ruby a MOP +✓ what should I say to Iceman? https://twitter.com/satisfiesvalues/status/1730025195413410129 +✓ footnote about FTX +✓ revision of "yelling" description pt. 3–5 prereaders— @@ -1406,6 +1356,7 @@ It even leaked into Big Yud!!! "Counterfactuals were made for humanity, not huma At least I don't have to link the rebuttal myself every time: https://www.datasecretslox.com/index.php/topic,1553.msg38755.html https://old.reddit.com/r/slatestarcodex/comments/10vx6gk/the_categories_were_made_for_man_not_man_for_the/j7k8fjc/ +https://twitter.com/niplav_site/status/1744304380503904616 ------ @@ -2845,3 +2796,28 @@ The man rewrote had rewritten my personality over the internet. Everything I do, ----- https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/kuqgJDPF6nfscSZsZ/thread-for-discussing-bostrom-s-email-and-apology?commentId=Z7kyiPAfmtztueFFJ + +---- + +"there just wasn't any reliable similarity between biology and AI" is an interesting contrast with the constant use of the evolution analogy despite credible challenges +https://twitter.com/ESYudkowsky/status/1738464784931025333 + +----- + +What if, in addition to physical punishments and Detect Thoughts, Cheliax also had Adjust Thoughts, a "gradient descent for the brain" spell (given a desired behavior, nudge the spell target's psychology to be more likely to emit that behavior)? Does Carissa still have a winning strategy? Assume whatever implementation details make for a good story. (Maybe Cheliax is reluctant to use Adjust Thoughts too much because Asmodeus wants authentic tyrannized humans, and the Adjust Thoughts sculpting makes them less tyrannized?) + +> One thing is sure, the path that leads to sanity and survival doesn't start with lies or with reasoning by Appeal to (Internal) Consequences. +https://twitter.com/ESYudkowsky/status/1743522277835333865 + +> To clarify a possibly misunderstood point: On my model, dath ilan's institutions only work because they're inhabited by dath ilani. Dath ilani invent good institutions even if they grow up in Earth; Governance on Earth lasts three days before Earth voters screw it up. +https://twitter.com/ESYudkowsky/status/1565516610286211072 + +July 2023 +https://twitter.com/pawnofcthulhu/status/1680840089285582848 +> man i feel like the orthodox viewpoint on this has moved on from "let's define trans women as women" to like +> "arguing about metaphysics is boring; letting people chose pronouns as part of self-expression seems like a thing a free society should allow for the same reason we should let people choose clothes; for many social purposes trans women are in fact empirically women" + +(If your "moderately serious" plan for survival is ["AI research journals banned, people violating that ban hunted down with partial effectiveness"](https://twitter.com/ESYudkowsky/status/1739705063768232070), that might be your least-bad option as a consequentialist, but one of the things your consequentialist calculation should take into account is that you've declared war on people who want to do AI science on Earth.) + +public intellectual death +https://scholars-stage.org/public-intellectuals-have-short-shelf-lives-but-why/ \ No newline at end of file