* "It can't be based on feelings"—hypocrisy, the only reason we're talking about this at all is because of genderspecial people's feelings, as explicitly acknowledged in the OP!!!
* "Can't imagine a sympathetic protagonist"—lies, imagine a rape victim
* "If there were unspeakable arguments against, we couldn't talk about them"—okay, then you and your rationalists are frauds
* "It can't be based on feelings"—hypocrisy, the only reason we're talking about this at all is because of genderspecial people's feelings, as explicitly acknowledged in the OP!!!
* "Can't imagine a sympathetic protagonist"—lies, imagine a rape victim
* "If there were unspeakable arguments against, we couldn't talk about them"—okay, then you and your rationalists are frauds